Skip to main content

Pickers vs. Throwers

If one would like to start a knitting version of a bar fight, ask which is the right way to knit, Continental (pickers) or English (throwers).  There are few who are neutral about their answer.

I learned how to knit using the English motion and have been using that style of knitting for decades.  Take a quick peek at this video it shows the amount of movement, especially in the right hand and arm.  See how the right hand is used to throw the working yarn around the needle.  This style of knitting can cause arm and shoulder pain if one knits for long lengths of time.  It is nonetheless a style of knitting used by millions of knitters.

There is evidence suggesting the use of the Continental style of knitting is easier on the arm and hand, faster and allows for more even tension.  Here's a video so you can see it in action. Note how the stitch is picked from the working yarn.  Additionally did you see how little overall movement there is in the hands?

I've tried to teach myself after watching videos with no success so when my LYS offered a class on how to learn Continental knitting style, I signed up for it.  Tena joined me; and today that class was held.

Like any time when one is trying to learn a new skill there is a certain amount of frustration.  It may be heighten if your skill is reasonably proficient doing it another way.  But I have to say today was enjoyable.  Judy, our instructor, gave clear, memorable instructions and plenty of time to practice under supervision.  And even though there were 8 of us in the class she was able to give us individual attention.  Judy also encouraged us to find our own ways to approaching Continental knitting to make it more comfortable.

Here's some photos of the class.  Note how each of us has a left index finger extended and how we are concentrating on what we're doing.  Both are necessary for this type of knitting for each of us at this point.

That's me on the left and our instructor Judy standing along with 2 classmates
My sample with the garter stitch on top and stockinette below, not bad for a beginner

Tena concentrating on her work
There will need to be lots of practicing of this new knitting technique, but Judy gave me the right type of direction to feel as if I'll be able to continue at home.  Once I have it fully conquered, Fair Isle knitting will be next, sometime in the distant future however.  The skill needs to be fully developed before then.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Anatomy of a Sock

I've been knitting socks for a relatively short time.  One of the disconcerting things for me as I started following patterns for socks is the pattern designer assumes the knitter (in this case that would be me) knows all the parts of a sock.  So I thought I'd devote a post to improve my own knowledge about the anatomy of a sock and maybe some of you will learn something about the humble yet necessary sock as well. Here's the names of the parts of the foot as I know them. #49 ankle, #50 heel, #51, instep, #52 ball, #53 big toe, #54 toe, #55 little toe, #56 toenail. There are some parts more important for this discussion; first the heel of a foot is generally used to refer to the entire C-shape from the ankle to the instep.  Speaking of the instep, it refers to that curve near the bottom of the foot.  And what seems to be missing in the design above is the sole which generally refers to the bottom of the foot in total or plantar aspect in more technical terms...
8 comments
Read more

Yarn Usage II: Crochet vs. Knit

All four swatches were made.  Each is 6.25" or 15.875 cm square; each prepared with the same sized yarn and needles or hook.  It took 25 stitches to get the appropriate width for the knit swatches and only 20 stitches for both of the crocheted squares.  That already says something, but I'll get to it in a minute.  (Don't know what I'm talking about here?  Check out this post first.) Unfortunately, you'll just have to trust me that four swatches were prepared and that they were all the same size.  In the excitement to get to measuring and weighing of the swatches, no photographic evidence was taken.  Luckily for me the results of this research doesn't have to be reviewed by a jury of my peer.  This blog post will be the sum and total of where this information is published. The remains of my four swatches What can be shared, however, are the balls of yarn rewound after the weighing and measuring was completed.  You will note the size ...
7 comments
Read more

Knitting-Related Guinness World Records

I had to share some of the Guinness World Records connected with knitting.  It is amazing to me the type of skill, stamina and unique characteristics these record holders have in common. How about trying to knit with these SPNs?? Ingrid Wagner and her large needles and knitted swatch The largest knitting needles measured 3.5 m (11 ft 5.8 in) long and had a diameter of 8 cm (3.15 in). Ingrid Wagner, a rug and art creation artist, from the UK used the needles to knit a tension square of ten stitches by ten rows at the Metro Radio Arena, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK, on March, 10 2008.  (And I complained about getting certain SPNs stuck in my clothes.)  See how this swatch was done with merely 5 people managing the needles.  And what about the yarn?  It is truly ex-bulky.  It looks like they're knitting in a warehouse, but with a wingspan of almost 24 feet or 7 m, you'd need all that space.  Or h...
7 comments
Read more